Summary

Here some points:

• I like the effect list on 18.12.. At least I'm used to that
• Also the favorite system for my workflow is confusing at the moment
• prefer an all A and V effects separated by categories, and a favorites that could be separated or combined with categories
• The favorite drop down that removes the effects from the main list is confusing
• remove favorite category: Maybe adding a star behind the name would be sufficient because favorites are at the top
• The categories could change to a folder based system, so we don't have to maintain the list on the rc file
• Blacklist effect: Maybe we could have a whitelist of curated effects, with an option to display all (non crashing) effects for users wanting it...
• Some effects don't crash ,but don't seem to do anything useful too, those should be hidden if nothing can be done on our side to make them work (gui wise)
• Rename back "compositions" to "transitions" (as in other video editors)
• Please fix the audio the GVerb filter
• Re-Implement 18.12 behevior to change transition type via properties tab. See #395

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

• Descriptions of the effects in 19.04: Effects_report.pdf
• CleaningEffects list: https://community.kde.org/Kdenlive/Development/CleaningEffects
• Online Excel list with all effects and compositions/transitions: https://lite.framacalc.org/kdenlive-effects -> all updated according 19.04 status [ME 22-Sep-19]
• Manual: Effects And Transitions: https://userbase.kde.org/Kdenlive/Manual/Effects_And_Transitions
• Custom effects list don't show the custom effects: https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=411871
• document to try to explain how compositing works and understand possible issues https://share.kde.org/s/aLqt54GGQWrwDYi and Project file used for this test https://share.kde.org/s/sdY8Aqzs6ow5MZ5
• Kdenlive 19.12 Effects Refactoring https://share.kde.org/s/5GMats9HNgeoL3e